Petersburg Man Faces Drug and Firearm Charges After Investigation

arrest-1-unsplash-150x150157366-1
arrest-1-unsplash-150x150157366-1

A Petersburg man is facing multiple felony charges following an investigation by the Pike County Sheriff’s Office. Prosecutors say 35-year-old Timothy Joseph Stelling has been charged with possession of a firearm by a prohibited person, dealing in methamphetamine, and maintaining a common nuisance, along with a habitual offender enhancement. The charges stem from a report of gunfire near a residence in the Glezen area on May 10. Investigators say the shots were traced to a camper where Stelling was living. Authorities determined he was on parole and not allowed to possess a firearm. The following day, deputies conducted a traffic stop on State Road 57 near the Gibson County line. During the investigation, Stelling reportedly told officers he had thrown a firearm into a river and later consented to a search of his camper. Officials say the search uncovered suspected methamphetamine, drug paraphernalia, and ammunition. According to court documents, Stelling also admitted to selling small amounts of methamphetamine. He was taken into custody and booked into the Pike County Jail. Prosecutors have requested an enhanced bond due to his prior criminal history. Authorities note that all charges are allegations and Stelling is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

 

Full News Release

May 12, 2026

Re: Timothy Joseph Stelling, 35, of Petersburg Charged with Possession of Methamphetamine and Maintaining a Common Nuisance

PETERSBURG, IN – The Pike County Prosecutor’s Office today filed felony charges against Timothy Joseph Stelling, 35, of Petersburg, Indiana, for Possession of Firearm by Prohibited Person, a level 4 Felony, Dealing in Methamphetamine, a Level 5 Felony, and Maintaining a Common Nuisance — Controlled Substances, a Level 6 Felony. A Habitual Offender sentencing enhancement has also been filed.

The charges arise from an investigation by Detective Scott Arnold of the Pike County Sheriff’s Office. On May 10, 2026, Detective Arnold received a report regarding erratic shooting in proximity to a residence off of County Road 125 in the Glezen area. Further investigation determined that the shooting emanated from a camper inhabited by Stelling, who was determined to be on parole and ineligible to possess firearms based on past felony convictions. On May 11, 2026, Chief Deputy Dallas Killian of the Pike County Sheriff’s Office observed Stelling commit a traffic violation and conducted a traffic stop on State Road 57 near the Gibson County line and notified Det. Arnold. Thereafter, the two of them Mirandized Stelling who told them he had thrown the pistol that he had been shooting “in the river” but also consented to a search of his camper.

A subsequent search of Stelling’s camper yielded suspected methamphetamine, multiple glass smoking devices, and pistol ammunition. According to the probable cause affidavit, after Stelling was Mirandized he admitted to selling methamphetamine to persons in small amounts so that he could support his living expenses. Stelling was arrested and booked into the Pike County Jail.

The State of Indiana has filed a Motion for Enhanced Bond citing Stelling’s convictions for Battery Resulting in Serious Bodily Injury, Domestic Battery, Possession of an Altered Firearm, Operating While Intoxicated, and Theft.

A Level 4 Felony carries a sentencing range of 2 to 12 years imprisonment. A Level 6 Felony carries a sentencing range of 6 months to 2.5 years. The Habitual Offender enhancement, if proven, provides for an additional fixed term of imprisonment of between 6 and 20 years.

The Office of the Pike County Prosecutor advises that under our Constitution, all individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law and, until such time, all charges are merely allegations and should be considered as such.

Darrin E. McDonald
Prosecuting Attorney

RecomMended Posts

Loading...